Perspective: A Day in the Life of Another Country’s Healthcare System

I will be the first one to admit that my job teaching English to privileged Korean children at a private academy has almost nothing to do with public health. While I have maintained most of my international-health related activities (and even added some new ones since being here), my income-generating activities are not typically health-related. There are times, however – and more than I originally expected, to be sure – when my public health knowledge and training comes in handy. For example, we have a lot of debate classes, and obesity, fast food, and eating disorders are frequent topics. It can be really enriching to bring my professional training into the classroom and engage my students beyond the textbook.

And then I occasionally get responses to writing assignments like these.
2013-01-21 20.59.36

If your first instinct is that this is just a witty response from a smart-ass middle school student, think again. I got two more with the same response.

2013-01-22 17.23.22

2013-01-21 20.59.36

Teacher, what?

By and large, South Korea’s healthcare system comes very highly reviewed. The government provides universal health coverage through the compulsory National Health Insurance scheme, which covers basic services – half of the premium is paid by the individual and the other half by that person’s employer. Experts and pundits love to list it as one of the examples that America’s own expensive and oh-so-broken system should aspire to be, as South Korea only spends about 7% of its GDP on health care (compared to our whopping 17%). Koreans, of course, take great pride in their healthcare system. A prime example can be found on the popular blog Ask a Korean, where the author writes about this very same topic.

Part of the reason why the Korean did not follow the [American healthcare debate] was because the entire thing was so moronic: to the Korean, it is obvious that a country should guarantee its citizens a health insurance, and the cheapest way to achieve that is a single-payer system like Korea’s. Scores of advanced and semi-advanced countries in the world manage to do this without turning their country into Russia. (Unless, of course, if their country is Russia.) There is no point in watching a debate where the other side is arguing the sky isn’t blue.

What has been strange for us to understand was not Koreans’ views on healthcare, but on accessing it. We noticed very early on that our Korean coworkers go to the hospital for everything – and by that, I mean everything. Have a stomachache? Time to go to the hospital. Sore throat? Going to the hospital. Cold? Hospital. Fever? Flu? Twitch under your eye? You get the idea. During our first few weeks, I was always very concerned to hear that someone had gone to the hospital, but now I don’t even bat an eye.

Coming from a country where healthcare is so expensive that people wait until they are at death’s door to get treated (and then, by necessity, have to go to the hospital), I found a system with the opposite problem to be somewhat fascinating. I asked one of my friends here, who is a neurologist at a local hospital, about it, and he explained some of the reasons behind this tendency:

  1. Many Koreans think that bigger is better, which means if they go to a hospital for a simple cold, they feel like they get better service than they would get from a small clinic.
  2. Also, many Koreans feel that they need to see someone who works at a reputable facility, graduated from a prestigious university, or has multiple advanced degrees to be satisfied, even for minor ailments.
  3. Third, he explained, Korea is still a hierarchical society, which means that upper-class individuals go to upscale hospitals for treatment to get the medical treatment they feel that they deserve according to your socioeconomic status.

In a system where a procedure costs the same amount no matter where you go, these reasons make sense, particularly in a culture that is as socially competitive as this one. Of course, every healthcare system has its own issues, and Korea is no exception. Because the price for a given procedure is the same everywhere and, as a result, larger hospitals have people lined up out the door to get their runny noses looked at, providers are pressured to see as many patients as possible in the shortest amount of time to minimize wait time and maximize profit. Absolutely everyone knows that this is a terrible idea, leading to stories like the one I read in the local English-language paper about a small colonoscopy clinic in Seoul that was seeing hundreds of patients per day – and not properly cleaning their instruments because they were so rushed. Also, much like the U.S., Korea is starting to see its healthcare costs rise and must come up with a way to continue to finance them, lest they become sustainable. Still, as Americans prepare themselves for the upcoming changes that the landmark healthcare reform will bring over the next few years, it is interesting to put the uproar into perspective.

Not all of the write-up books that I received were so drastic in their responses to the runny nose question. Two of my best students also gave me slightly more sensible answers.

2013-01-23 14.13.52

2013-01-23 14.13.07

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s